WASTE WATCH: Costly Court Cases in Conflict

Updated: Wednesday, May 7 2014, 09:55 AM EDT
WASTE WATCH: Costly Court Cases in Conflict story image
COLUMBUS (Brooks Jarosz) -- Judges are supposed to be impartial but dozens of their cases have financial conflicts.

It's not just a matter of ethics, it's a matter of money since some cases now have to be re-tried.

Judges are required to report most financial information like stocks, investments and gifts from companies in order to determine if there is a conflict of interest in the cases they hear. However, one non-profit group uncovered that judges face no formal punishment for breaking those rules.

A judgment may be made, but numerous federal cases are reopened after a judge sends a letter admitting a conflict of interest discovered later. For example, one case involving the City of Columbus and Hotels.com involved a judge who owned stock in Priceline, which created conflict.

Non-profit Center for Public Integrity, found 26 federal cases with conflicts since 2010.

"Few of us know who these judges are or know about the things that economically influence their interest," law professor Christopher Fairman said.

Ohio State Associate Dean Christopher Fairman teaches at the Moritz College of Law. He says all judges are required to report certain financial information, but many times, details about gifts, income and investments is blacked out. That means if the conflict is caught months or in some cases, years later, it becomes costly.

"Certainly we're talking tens of thousands of dollars in order to retry cases -- even the small ones," Fairman said.

Federal financial disclosures is far more specific than the state. Ohio received an "F” rating by the Center for Integrity. ABC 6 Investigators found Ohio Supreme Court justices don't have to report specific income, transactions or any investment amounts.

Fairman is concerned that there are far more cases of conflict in the state and argues the disclosure requirements need to charge in order to protect people coming before the bench.

"So the more information that we have about their interests, the better off we are to make decisions about whether they should be sitting on your case or your dispute," Fairman said.

The problem with state financial disclosure is really in the paperwork since judges only have to report who gave a gift or contribution but don't have to say what it was or the value.

Several Ohio Supreme Court justices received gifts from state lawmakers after getting elected but it's not clear how much those gifts were worth.

Other reporting requirements are vague and don't specify details.

In the end, several lawyers told ABC 6 Investigators they hope the judicial system will increase what has to be reported in hopes judges will be mandated to be more open and transparent in the future.

News Links:
Do you know what appellate judges in your area own? Click here to find out!WASTE WATCH: Costly Court Cases in Conflict
comments powered by Disqus

Government Accountability Office

Citizens Against Government Waste

National Tax Payers Union

Government Accountability Project

CATO Institute

Waste Watch

Waste Watch National Stories

Mad Rush To Spend Taxpayer Money
Army Can't Track Spending On A System Designed To Track Spending
Did The U.S. Need A New Military Facility?
How About A Bowl Of Pork To Go With A Plate Of Defense
How Will Hurricane Tax Dollars Be Spent This Time?
Lunch On Taxpayers
A Fishy Federal Program
Should Taxpayers Pay For All Research Studies?
Charitable Misgiving
Taxpayer Subsidized Plane Rides
Tax Breaks For Oil And Gas Companies
DOE Giving Away Money
Federal Building Makeovers
More Food Stamps, Fewer Women Working Full Time
The Top Taxpayer Flops, Follies, & Fiascoes
Stimulus Spending Goes To The Dogs
Federal Employees Fly First Class
A Movie Ending That Only Hollywood Loves
Farm Bill More Pork, Less Beef
Lunch On Taxpayers
The Waste Between The Lines
U.S. Spends Billions Helping Foreign Countries Fight Climate Change
The Wastebook
Health and Human Services Wastes Millions on Cancer Drug
Waste In Washington
Your Tax Dollars Used for Big Screen Televisions, Jewelry, Art, and More
Tracking Your Tax Dollars
How Much Fraud is Connected to Social Security Disability Benefits?
Surgery often covered by Medicare is raising eyebrows
Are Maryland Lawmakers Taking Vacations on Your Dime?
Is playing the Powerball a bad bet?
Foreign Research Projects: What do Taxpayers get?
What did Taxpayers get for $50 million?
Big Government
IRS Conferences
Disability Nation
Teaching Fish how to Survive
Teaching Poetry to Prisoners
Do We Still Need DHS?
Free Phones
Feds and Meds
Pole Dancing
Payday Loans
The Cost of Amnesty
Making Tough Cuts
The Business Reality of Obamacare
Federal Government Duplication
Taxpayers Pay for Nothing
Abusing a Federal Program
Medicaid Mess
Victims of Government
Taxpayers Bail Out Carnival
Congress is Still Flying the World Over
The Show Goes on at the White House, Despite Sequester
The Cost of Redundacy
A Long Wait for Veterans
Presidents Cost Millions
Graphic Federal Ad Campaign to get People to Stop Smoking
Tax Liens Could Doom Federal Workers
The IRS Star Trek Spoof
Golf but no Tours
How Taxes Mold a State
Congress and Pay
The Rich and Taxes
Immigration Reform
Job Training
Missed Taxes
Congressional Perks
Tracking Federal Money
The 112th Congress
Good Deal or Dud for Taxpayers?
Some Lawmakers are Addicted to Tobacco Cessation Money
Loan a Drone
Sen. Coburn Says Yes to Tax Hikes
Spending at the Department of Homeland Security
Waste at the Pentagon
Sandy Relief
Utility Waste
Fiscal Cliff
Mortgage Interest Deduction
Fourth Major 'Green' Company Files for Bankruptcy Under the Obama Administration
The Waste Book
Tank Spending
Medicare Fraud, Waste & Abuse
Fiscal Cliff
Romney Remarks Backlash
The Federal Environmental Protection Agency Funds a Newspaper
Production Halted on the Chevy Volt
Senator Tom Coburn Talks About Waste at the Congressional Level
Federal Pay Freeze Extended
Making Money Off a Storm
Political Ads or the Official Business of the White House?
A Federal Program Designed to Help Disabled Veterans Grow Small Businesses Handed Out Tens of Millions of Dollars to Everyone but Disabled Veterans
The Food Stamp Program Costs Taxpayers About $80 Billion a Year and Critics Say a Large Percentage of that is Tied to Waste, Fraud and Abuse
GSA Caught on Another Spending Spree
How Much Did that Rap Video Cost You?
Taxpayers Shell out Millions for the House and Senate
Do Lawmakers Spend too Much Time and Money on Resolutions?
Congress Spends Millions on Printing Costs
Senate Dems Spend Millions Debating Bill That Won't Pass
Fisker Gets $200 Million Grant But Produces No Cars
Congress Spending Thousands of Dollars Every Month on Bottled Water
Congress Spending Hundreds of Thousands of Dollars on Calendars
Lawmaker Call For End of Free Cell Phone Program
advertisement
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
advertisement